Park / Earthsea - The Tomb's of Atuan

Who would you choose as winner of this matchup?

2 Comments

This park shares comments with 1 other park(View Park)
  • Kumba%s's Photo
    Posted Image

    Match-Up #22: Xcoaster vs. jusmith

    #1 Xcoaster with his entry:
    Earthsea - The Tomb's of Atuan

    Posted Image

    #16 jusmith with his entry:
    Enchanted Heights

    Posted Image

    After 4 votes by the judges, the winner, by a score of 3 to 1, is... Xcoaster

    Xcoaster advances to round two where he will meet DelLagos in what could be a pretty good match-up of two creative and unpredictable parkmakers.

    OLE's writeup
    Yet another newcomer, jusmith, faces the highly skilled Parkmaker Xcoaster here in the 22nd match of Round 1. What looked to be a blowout ended up being a little closer than expected. Jusmith came in pretty strong with a well themed entry called Enchanted Heights. The architecture relies heavily on grey stone walls that's built up and around a little waterfall to create a ruined castle atmosphere. A dive machine that has a nice but pretty standard layout is the only ride on the map. Overall the use of grey makes it a little dull and the building forms are simple but it's an unexpected good first showing for him here at NE. A lot was expected of Xcoaster with his highly detailed style but he didn't quite live up to those expectations here in Round 1. His entry, Earthsea-The Tombs of Atuan ended up pretty bare with only one building and not a whole lot of theming. A sprawling wooden coaster meanders its way across the map, its station being the ruined tomb. Some attractive uses of mazes and building blocks are used as theming for the ride. It was a bit of a letdown considering what Xcoaster usually makes but it wasn't a bad entry. Jusmith actually managed to get 1 vote but even with his B game Xcoaster is a tough opponent and the final score ended up 3-1.

    Winner: Xcoaster
  • J K%s's Photo
    I have respect for Jusmith for not backing down from such a great parkmaker. Nice round guys. Good luck for the competition Xcoaster.
  • Levis%s's Photo
    you know ryan ... I think I would have loved it even more if it wasn't a ruin :p I think the original thing looked awesome :p , still this entry is very nice to !