Music Forum / my band (Planetary Archive)

Just re-read my post above. No idea why I had to sound so negative. Sorry Sam. Do keep us posted on the band.

have to say I listened to it and I have to say, singing isn't your strongest feature, songwriting might be nice but the singing just kills it for me tbh, it's sometimes out of tune and I'm very nitpicky about that since I'm the singer of my band aswell and I know how hard it is and I'm not saying I'm perfect but it sometimes sounds too forced in specific parts as I listened, especially the higher notes sound like you have a hard time reaching them properly, again I'm no expert but I think you need to work on that to improve the quality of the music...

while it's not my taste in music it's well written but some aspects need work like the singing since I do listen very carefully to that part

if only i was a cool guy like you

I'm not saying I'm better, I'm not that arrogant if that's what you recieved from my post...
it just needs some work and you're getting there but it needs work, I need work too and I know that but it's almost like your voice has a tone that isn't suited for the music you're making it's very low and growly and with that kinda musical play in terms of riffs I'd think a thinner voice would be better suited... like have you ever tried long parts of falsetto or anything to make it sound more "airy"? could do you wonders and it's easier to go for the higher notes that way...

I wouldn't say his comment was very nice, but tongue-in-cheek insulting is way too common at NE ("Robbie you suck balls") to condemn just a single member.

but the conceit of jokes like that is "robbie is such a fantastic player it's given that it's an absurdity to criticize his work" (which isnt necessarily a position i endorse), not expressing actual dislike, which sf did do

BG: I wholeheartedly think that your comments would come across more nicely if you used periods. At all.

ain't nobody got time fo that! XD

dunno might look into that remark

I like the rhythm in the riff of the song in the link there. But some of your stuff sound the same. Can't really hear what you're singing, but that's the norm with live gigs.

Sort of reminds me of an early Smashing Pumpkins, but I couldn't hear the vocals too well in the video. Keep it up, even if some people here don't like it, I'm sure there will be plenty of fans out there for ya