H2H3 / Official Captain Veto Thread

Just post wether you veto or not and for what waiver action.

I veto the Jellybones for Adonis move.

who said we could even veto?
how about you chill?

corkscrewed is a trustworthy person, i'm sure he'll agree about the trade being unfair and find a solution that makes all of you happy.

Personaly I'm fine with Evil being the captain and replacement for Toon and would just suggest anyone else from the list other then Adonis to replace Moon.

[font="tahoma"]who said we could even veto?
how about you chill?

corkscrewed is a trustworthy person, i'm sure he'll agree about the trade being unfair and find a solution that makes all of you happy.[/font]

Read the rules its in there.

-If a player drops out, the coach may not choose any player he wants to replace them. He must choose a player off the Replacement List, and the player must be approved by all coaches, to prevent less talented players to be replaced by superstars.

Im gona need to Veto. yes you lost Toon & iris, but you got a really good parkmaker in Evil WME, and id guess iris did most of the captain tasks alreddy. but MoonSpoon for Voodoo is in no way fair, also id veto if you went for Alec (AK).

Ok so thats my veto, TPM's and Chapels. WME can't vote, and im not sure what Posix and Gym think but its 3 of 5. Sorry Voodoo, id like to see you in this, but thats just not fair. So I guess this is a done deal unless the rules get changed...

Evil my advice to you is to take Splash-O. he is better then Moon IMO, but not insanely better like Voodoo would be.

Chapel has proof to back him up. I apologize for this, because I forgot about that rule (to be honest). We will have to work out a compromise.

Personally, I think Evil WME and Adonis basically equals Toon and Jellybones. However, the approval rule was set in stone well before we every did any of this, so it would hold precedence.

Anyway, my bad folks.

copying what I posted in the other thread:




EDIT:
Okay, actually, I've come to a conclusion. In re-reading the rules and regulations, I've realized a couple of things. The following ruling affects the IIIcons AND the Flying Germans, because both have recently PM'ed me about dropping players and stuff.

In the Rules, it states:

-If a player drops out, the coach may not choose any player he wants to replace them. He must choose a player off the Replacement List, and the player must be approved by all coaches, to prevent less talented players to be replaced by superstars.

Meaning that yeah, I screwed up the handling of the waiver.

HOWEVER, those drops should not have been allowed in the first place, as evidenced by this rule:

-No coach may try and persuade any players into doing something they can't. For instance, if a player cannot go three times, the coach can not punish or replace the player. If the player can not play a certain game that the coach wants, the coach can not punish or replace the player. You should have known these things when you drafted them.

Basically, the replacement list is only for players who willingly drop on their own. They have to say that they're dropping out (as was Toon's case, I believe). A captain, however, cannot drop a player just because he's been inactive. Therefore, Evil WME was not allowed to drop Jellybones unless Jellybones posted in this forum that he was dropping. Similarly, Posix cannot drop the player he PM'ed me to drop. It's easier to make this ruling on Posix's team than WME's, because Mark didn't actually draft his team; Iris did. However, in taking on the role of captain, he basically inherited Iris's roles and responsibilities and accepted that he'd have to sort out the mess of the team.

So for now, I'm afraid I am going to have to void all transactions. That means Adonis is still a free agent and Jellybones is still on the team. Furthermore, though I haven't announced it, the move Posix was going to make is also voided.


IIIcons and Flying Germans members: I will be sending you new passwords for your forums, so please check your PMs shortly. I take responsibility for the mess that this has caused. The reason I am changing the passwords for your teams is to preserve the integrity of each forum. Because Adonis probably has the password to the IIIcons forums, even though he has been taken off the team, there's the whole secrecy deal. Also, Posix might have relayed the password to his team forum to the person he wanted to pick up. I trust everyone not to blab, but just to be safe, I'm changing the passwords, just so there are no seams.

To Adonis, I apologize for having you pulled this way and that. To the captains, I apologize for forgetting the rules on this matter. To Evil WME, I apologize for making the controversial move to retract your waiver move. I know losing Toon was a big blow, and you can use the help, but at the same time, part of H2H and any sport is the necessity to deal with stuff that happens. And though it sounds harsh, you're going to have to deal with Jellybones being less active. Besides, you still have a pretty damn good team as it stands. I mean... Phatage, WME, Janus, and Metro have all shown some great stuff lately.

Just to clarify, here is the OFFICIAL CURRENT ROSTER of the IIIcons and the Flying Germans.

IIIcons:
1.Evil WME (Parkmaking Captain)
2.Phatage
3.DarkJanus
4.Metropole
5.Blitz-sama
6.maggi1703
7.Rct Flame
8.Outlaw
9.Red_Ant_Skittles
10.MoonSpoon

Flying Germans:
-Captain: Posix (non-participating captain)
1.x-sector
2.ride6
3.X250
4.leighx
5.RCTFAN
6.Mindbender5
7.disneylandian192
8.jon
9.Valp
10.rctfan1556

Jellybones did in fact ask to leave, he wasn't dropped.

I need him to make a post in the Replacements topic or in this forum for it to be official. Technically, for all I know, you could be making it up (not that I'm saying you are, but just adhering to the rules... now that I'm clear on them).

FUCK! Cork... *shakes head*

That does not make things any better. I know it won't help me but here's the exact quote from RCT FAN:

Hey thought i would say something.

Like the screens, don't know what i will be able to do though.

ive not been inspired to play since october

That's it, word for word and he hasn't posted anything since or replied to Posix's PM and its been over a week. You should be able to use your web-god (moderating) powers to check that and I request that you do. This guy wants to leave.

Now I'm pretty pissed because we're only trying to replace a good player who's gone with another that's about equal. Oh and in case you're wondering this is posix's post that follows it:

your problem. you signed up for h2h3, you must be reliable.

Harsh? Maybe. But we would like this guy to play. He's choosing not to.

ride6

Chill. We're just redoing the process correctly this time.

Jellybones did in fact ask to leave, he wasn't dropped.

that's what jellybones said:

Um. I'm dropping out.

Sorry to spring this on you. But I will be much easier to replace than say, Toon, or Iris.

Sorry.

could you please let your captains handle this?

I say, move this topic to the captain's lounge!

we already have one, thank you.