H2H8 / H2H8 Guess the Builder

  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo

    Someone had this idea on Discord, and I thought it would be fun. I'll be posting new polls in this thread for each match of each round, and when the builders are revealed for each park we can see who got the correct.
     
    There's an option for if you know who built, so everyone can participate!
     
    The results are hidden for now, and I'll organize who voted what when the builders are revealed.
     
    Scoring:
    1 Correct = 1 Point
    2 Correct = 2 Points
    3 Correct = 4 Points
    Floaters are worth half a point and don't count towards the number of builders guessed; there is also a penalty for just randomly guessing floaters.
     
    In other words...
    Floaters will be worth a flat 0.5 points, but if you guess a floater that didn't build, you lose 0.5 points.
     
    This should promote actually trying to determine if the floater built rather than just randomly guessing floaters all the time. (Looking at you, ref.) Because I was slow to perfect the system, I'll be lenient for Round 1 parks. Round 2 will include point reductions.
     
    Prizes? Maybe! Depends on participation.
     
    Survey for Round 1; Match 3:
    https://goo.gl/forms/Uay2s33nfpnjvLw53 Closed
     
    Survey for Round 1; Match 2:
    https://goo.gl/forms/f7RfY9IM8kc1lgUi2 Closed
     
    Survey for Round 1; Match 1:
    https://goo.gl/forms/esMeTrI6348cm9wv1 Closed
     
    Round 2; Match 1
    https://goo.gl/forms/vALBRJDpHUeHav5u2 Closed
     
    Round 2; Match 2
    https://goo.gl/forms/yyoavHkA2UKikwU43 Closed

    Round 2; Match 3
    https://goo.gl/forms/58kVeqpIF4JK6U3p2 Closed
     
    Round 3; Match 1
    https://goo.gl/forms/vdbIk9InHgQfwNKe2 Closed
     
    Round 3; Match 2
    https://goo.gl/forms/89Zj8gDyqcr4FSRg1 Closed
     
    Round 3; Match 3
    https://goo.gl/forms/kX3ChOb9CFIPNmED3 Closed
     
    Round 4; Match 1
    https://goo.gl/forms/JIKQDd6UzzPboPQK2 Closed
     
    Round 4; Match 2
    https://goo.gl/forms/jrcP94lFcToYI9rB3 Closed

     

    Round 4; Match 3

    https://goo.gl/forms/engyXnORCMAoWvv62 Closed

     

    Round 5; Match 1

    https://goo.gl/forms/FyFmq0OqHCJSJSZB2 Closed

     

    Round 5; Match 2

    https://goo.gl/forms/Q6WUjuDiKbnB5mPJ2 Closed

     

    Semis 1

    https://goo.gl/forms/h6t6EKZ4TVaWNZjT2

     

    Final

    https://goo.gl/forms/hTrpGawjHc4KSSCt2

     
    Scoreboard (Overall):
     

    chorkiel 53.5
    Bubbsy41 51
    Scoop 49.5
    shot guns 46
    AvanineCommuter 45
    RWE 44.5
    MK98 40.5
    saxman1089 37
    CoasterCreator9 37
    Sulakke 37
    Recurious 35.5
    Liampie 34.5
    dr dirt 34.5
    FredD 32.5
    Fisch 32
    Camcorder22 30
    cocoa 27.5
    Robbie92 27
    Ottersalad 25.5
    MrBrightside711 23
    G Force 22.5
    Faas 20.5
    Iron Rattler 18
    Version1 14
    djbrcace1234 12
    WhosLeon 11.5
    GammaZero 11.5
    ultro 10
    IonZer0 7.5
    Austin55 7.5
    Tom_DJ 7
    nin 6
    CHE 5
    Steve 4
    Thethrillman 3.5
    Six Frags 3.5
    gdb 3
    alex 3
    Tolsimir 2
    merzbow666 2
    CedarPoint6 2
    Spacek531 2
    Milo 1.5
    Impulse 1
    trav 1
    Wouter VL 0.5
    zxbiohazardzx 0.5
    bigshootergill 0
  • BelgianGuy%s's Photo

    having been part of the frankenstein thread I really don't like the idea of this...

  • AvanineCommuter%s's Photo

    having been part of the frankenstein thread I really don't like the idea of this...


    Frankenstein thread? Pray tell more...?
  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo


    having been part of the frankenstein thread I really don't like the idea of this...

     

    I don't anticipate anything like that occurring this H2H, honestly. Just meant to be a bit of fun to see who can best recognize the styles of those involved.

  • Kumba%s's Photo

    Floaters are worth half a point and don't count towards the overall score.

    So they have worth despite being worthless :???:

  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo

    So they have worth despite being worthless :???:

     

    Liam's idea; I thought it was a good idea.

     

    To elaborate; anyone can guess the floater on every single park.

  • Bubbsy41%s's Photo
    edit
  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo

    First post has been updated with the second match.

  • Recurious%s's Photo

    So I realized an obvious flaw in the system that you are using. You get points for every park maker you guess correct but there is no maximum amount of votes or penalties for voting wrongly. Therefore if I select all park makers every time I can never lose because I will always have all the people correct..

  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo


    So I realized an obvious flaw in the system that you are using. You get points for every park maker you guess correct but there is no maximum amount of votes or penalties for voting wrongly. Therefore if I select all park makers every time I can never lose because I will always have all the people correct..

     

    So far people have been following it appropriately, but I'll see if I can change it to a maximum of four guesses. Otherwise, I can just disregard any submission that does that. 

  • G Force%s's Photo
    Just set a four guess limit for each park.
  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo

    Just set a four guess limit for each park.

     

    Found it; should be all set. 

  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo

    Topic updated for Match 1! Good luck guessing, everyone.

  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo

    Lots of stuff happening today; here are the raw results for guesses during the first match:

     

    Attached Image: Chart 1.PNG

    Attached Image: Chart 2.PNG

     

    Interesting Observations:

    - Wit's End was significantly harder for people to guess

    - Only one person (Bubbsy41) got all builders correct

    - alex as a builder was a surprise for many on Wit's End

    - trav's guessing style

     

    Don't forget to vote for the other matches!

  • ][ntamin22%s's Photo
    I am astonished there are 0s for match one

    This means those people failed to guess Liam
  • inthemanual%s's Photo

    Can we see who guessed who? I'd be interested to see who thought me, and what trav voted.

  • Coasterbill%s's Photo

    I really thought BSG had a hand in Durham, Knaresborough & Staithes. Those cute 2x2 buildings and the lighthouse screamed BSG to me, and since I know he's a fast builder I would have thought ht would have gone in Round 1. I didn't vote, but if I did I would have been dead wrong. Liam building on this was obvious since he always comes out swinging. Same goes for Shogo.

  • CoasterCreator9%s's Photo

    Who guessed who:

     

    Attached Image: Guesses 1.PNG
    Attached Image: Guesses 2.PNG
     
    After some discussion on Discord; I'm going to try to factor in the floaters.
     
    Floaters will be worth a flat 0.5 points, but if you guess a floater that didn't build, you lose 0.5 points.
     
    This should promote actually trying to determine if the floater built rather than just guessing floaters all the time.
  • Milo%s's Photo

    I sit on a throne of lies.

  • AvanineCommuter%s's Photo
    Everybody is a FOOL.

Tags

  • No Tags

Members Reading