RCT Discussion / Knockout: RCT2 Designs Group A

So this went well, huh? I think we need a new approach to this. 160+ Designs to rank just seems so outrageous. Maybe reduce to a top 20 based on panel/community ratings? I dunno.

We just have to get rid of the boring ones. And now that we got to the second page, some people can vote again. Also, let's now start with giving four pairs of -1/+1s., make this game more attractive.

 

Here are some links to some design, in case people want to check them out quickly:

http://www.nedesigns.../230/vermilion/

http://www.nedesigns...park/762/mayra/

http://www.nedesigns...ark/59/chamois/

http://www.nedesigns...us-carcharodon/

http://www.nedesigns...k/225/chamonix/

http://www.nedesigns...k/214/big-bear/

http://www.nedesigns...645/hammerhead/

http://www.nedesigns...rk/115/mordred/

http://www.nedesigns...k/1985/vulture/

http://www.nedesigns...ark/1501/pixie/

http://www.nedesigns...time-continuum/

http://www.nedesigns.../579/yggdrasil/

http://www.nedesigns...park/210/siren/

 

10 - Archimedes +1
5 - Big Bear 
8 - Brachiosaurus +1
10 - Cedar Point's Raptor
3 - Chamois -1
7 - Chamonix
7 - Extinction 
5 - Genus Carcharodon
7 - Ghostliner
6 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
3 - Hammerhead -1
4 - Herne the Hunter
2 - Journey to Atlantis -1
4 - Katakiuchi 
7 - KINDRED
5 - Mayra
3 - Mordred 
7 - Pixie
7- Rougarou
4 - Siren -1
6 - Space Time Continuum +1
9 - Starflight +1
4 - Swoon 
4 - Tomahawk
3 - Vermilion
7 - Vulture
6 - windsweep 
4 - Yggdrasil

I agree with Steve, there's just too many and no one can be arsed. I'd just do the top 20.

10 - Archimedes

4 - Big Bear -1
8 - Brachiosaurus
10 - Cedar Point's Raptor
3 - Chamois
8 - Chamonix +1
7 - Extinction 
5 - Genus Carcharodon
7 - Ghostliner
6 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
3 - Hammerhead 
4 - Herne the Hunter
2 - Journey to Atlantis 
5 - Katakiuchi +1
7 - KINDRED
5 - Mayra
4 - Mordred  +1
7 - Pixie
7- Rougarou
4 - Siren 
5 - Space Time Continuum  -1
10 - Starflight +1
4 - Swoon 
4 - Tomahawk
3 - Vermilion
7 - Vulture
5 - windsweep -1
3 - Yggdrasil -1

11 - Archimedes +1

4 - Big Bear
8 - Brachiosaurus
11 - Cedar Point's Raptor +1
3 - Chamois
8 - Chamonix
7 - Extinction 
5 - Genus Carcharodon
7 - Ghostliner
6 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
3 - Hammerhead 
4 - Herne the Hunter
1 - Journey to Atlantis  -1
6 - Katakiuchi +1
7 - KINDRED
4 - Mayra -1
4 - Mordred
7 - Pixie
7- Rougarou
3 - Siren -1
5 - Space Time Continuum
10 - Starflight
4 - Swoon 
4 - Tomahawk
3 - Vermilion
8 - Vulture  +1
5 - windsweep
2 - Yggdrasil -1

11 - Archimedes

4 - Big Bear
8 - Brachiosaurus
12 - Cedar Point's Raptor +1
3 - Chamois
8 - Chamonix
8 - Extinction +1
5 - Genus Carcharodon
7 - Ghostliner
7 - Goliath +1
4 - Halcón Azul
3 - Hammerhead 
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
7 - KINDRED
4 - Mayra
4 - Mordred
7 - Pixie
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren -1
5 - Space Time Continuum
10 - Starflight
4 - Swoon 
4 - Tomahawk
2 - Vermilion -1
9 - Vulture +1
5 - windsweep
1 - Yggdrasil -1

 

0- Journey to Atlantis -1

Hey, we're getting somewhere. The game should get easier as more shitty obscure ones get eliminated.

 

12 - Archimedes +1
4 - Big Bear
9 - Brachiosaurus +1
12 - Cedar Point's Raptor
2 - Chamois -1
9 - Chamonix +1
8 - Extinction
5 - Genus Carcharodon
7 - Ghostliner
7 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
2  - Hammerhead -1
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
7 - KINDRED
4 - Mayra
3 - Mordred -1
7 - Pixie
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
11 - Starflight +1
4 - Swoon
4 - Tomahawk
1 - Vermilion -1
9 - Vulture
5 - windsweep
1 - Yggdrasil

12 - Archimedes 

3 - Big Bear -1
10 - Brachiosaurus +1
12 - Cedar Point's Raptor
1 - Chamois -1
9 - Chamonix

8 - Extinction
5 - Genus Carcharodon
7 - Ghostliner
7 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
2  - Hammerhead 
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
8 - KINDRED +1
4 - Mayra
3 - Mordred
7 - Pixie
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
12 - Starflight +1
4 - Swoon
5 - Tomahawk +1
1 - Vermilion 
9 - Vulture
5 - windsweep

 

Eliminated:

Vermilion
Yggdrasil

 

I refuse to allow starflight to get outdone by raptor

13 - Archimedes (+1)

3 - Big Bear
10 - Brachiosaurus
12 - Cedar Point's Raptor
10 - Chamonix (+1)

8 - Extinction
4 - Genus Carcharodon (-1)
8 - Ghostliner
7 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
1  - Hammerhead (-1)
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
8 - KINDRED
4 - Mayra
3 - Mordred
8 - Pixie (+1)
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight (+1)
3 - Swoon (-1)
5 - Tomahawk
9 - Vulture
5 - windsweep

 

Eliminated: 

Chamois (-1)

13 - Archimedes 

2 - Big Bear (-1)
10 - Brachiosaurus
12 - Cedar Point's Raptor
10 - Chamonix

9 - Extinction (+1)
5 - Genus Carcharodon (+1)
8 - Ghostliner
7 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
4 - Herne the Hunter
7 - Katakiuchi (+1)
8 - KINDRED
4 - Mayra
2 - Mordred (-1)
7 - Pixie (-1) 
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
3 - Swoon
5 - Tomahawk
10 - Vulture (+1)
5 - windsweep

 

Eliminated

0  - Hammerhead (-1)

13 - Archimedes 

3 - Big Bear (+1)
10 - Brachiosaurus (+1)
13 - Cedar Point's Raptor (+1)
10 - Chamonix

9 - Extinction
5 - Genus Carcharodon
8 - Ghostliner
7 - Goliath
4 - Halcón Azul
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi (-1)
9 - KINDRED (+1)
3 - Mayra (-1)
2 - Mordred
7 - Pixie 
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
2 - Swoon (-1)
5 - Tomahawk
9 - Vulture (-1)
5 - windsweep

13 - Archimedes 

3 - Big Bear
11 - Brachiosaurus (+1)
13 - Cedar Point's Raptor
10 - Chamonix

9 - Extinction
4 - Genus Carcharodon (-1)
9 - Ghostliner (+1)
7 - Goliath
3 - Halcón Azul (-1)
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
9 - KINDRED
2 - Mayra (-1)
1 - Mordred (-1)
8 - Pixie (+1)
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
2 - Swoon
6 - Tomahawk (+!)
9 - Vulture
5 - windsweep

I can't even remember half of these...

 

13 - Archimedes 

3 - Big Bear
11 - Brachiosaurus 
13 - Cedar Point's Raptor (+1)
10 - Chamonix

9 - Extinction
5 - Genus Carcharodon (+1)
9 - Ghostliner 
7 - Goliath
3 - Halcón Azul 
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
9 - KINDRED

237 - Kumba
1 - Mayra (-1)
8 - Pixie 
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
2 - Swoon
6 - Tomahawk 
9 - Vulture
5 - windsweep

 

0 - Mordred (-1)

13 - Archimedes 

3 - Big Bear
11 - Brachiosaurus 
12 - Cedar Point's Raptor -1
10 - Chamonix

9 - Extinction
5 - Genus Carcharodon
9 - Ghostliner 
7 - Goliath
3 - Halcón Azul 
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
9 - KINDRED

1 - Mayra
8 - Pixie 
7- Rougarou
2 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
3 - Swoon +1
5 - Tomahawk -1
9 - Vulture
6 - windsweep +1

We're doing +4/-4 aren't we?

 

14 - Archimedes +1

2 - Big Bear -1
11 - Brachiosaurus 
13 - Cedar Point's Raptor +1
10 - Chamonix

9 - Extinction
5 - Genus Carcharodon
9 - Ghostliner 
7 - Goliath
2 - Halcón Azul -1
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
10 - KINDRED +1

1 - Mayra
9 - Pixie +1
7- Rougarou
1 - Siren -1
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
2 - Swoon -1
5 - Tomahawk
9 - Vulture
6 - windsweep

We're doing +4/-4 aren't we?

I'm kind of just going with the amount that I feel like when posting. Keeping the amount of plus and minus the same though.

 

13 - Archimedes -1

2 - Big Bear
11 - Brachiosaurus 
13 - Cedar Point's Raptor
10 - Chamonix

9 - Extinction
5 - Genus Carcharodon
9 - Ghostliner 
7 - Goliath
2 - Halcón Azul
4 - Herne the Hunter
6 - Katakiuchi
10 - KINDRED

9 - Pixie
7- Rougarou
1 - Siren
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
3 - Swoon +1

4 - Tomahawk -1
10 - Vulture +1
7 - windsweep +1

 

0 - Mayra -1

14 - Archimedes (+1) 

1 - Big Bear (-1)
12 - Brachiosaurus (+1)
13 - Cedar Point's Raptor
10 - Chamonix

10 - Extinction (+1)
5 - Genus Carcharodon
9 - Ghostliner 
7 - Goliath
2 - Halcón Azul
3 - Herne the Hunter (-1)
6 - Katakiuchi
10 - KINDRED

8 - Pixie (-1)
7- Rougarou
5 - Space Time Continuum
13 - Starflight
3 - Swoon

4 - Tomahawk
11 - Vulture (+1)
7 - windsweep

 

0 - Siren (-1)

14 - Archimedes 

12 - Brachiosaurus
13 - Cedar Point's Raptor
11 - Chamonix (+1)

10 - Extinction 
5 - Genus Carcharodon

10 - Ghostliner (+1)
7 - Goliath
1 - Halcón Azul (-1)
3 - Herne the Hunter 
6 - Katakiuchi
10 - KINDRED

9 - Pixie (+1)
7- Rougarou
5 - Space Time Continuum
14 - Starflight (+1)
2 - Swoon (-1)

4 - Tomahawk
10 - Vulture (-1)
7 - windsweep

 

 

0 - Big Bear (-1)

I didn't expect Big Bear to fall so soon. I think the coaster is very cool. Even though it's a Thrillmatic rip.

14 - Archimedes 

12 - Brachiosaurus
14 - Cedar Point's Raptor +1
11 - Chamonix

11 - Extinction +1
5 - Genus Carcharodon

10 - Ghostliner
8 - Goliath +1
3 - Herne the Hunter 
6 - Katakiuchi
10 - KINDRED

9 - Pixie
6- Rougarou -1
5 - Space Time Continuum
14 - Starflight
1 - Swoon -1

4 - Tomahawk
10 - Vulture
7 - windsweep

 

0 - Halcón Azul -1